Packaging for Sweet Success

Whimsy cookie packaging

The first time Laurie Suriff and Collins Tuohy met, magic happened.

“I started making cookies out of my home in 2006,” Suriff says. “I loved baking with my mom. When my husband needed something to take to his clients, I suggested Mom’s sugar cookies. I made them and decorated them with a logo.”

Suriff’s cookie decorating skills and her mom’s secret recipe were a hit. News spread and she began selling cookies to family, friends, and co-workers. Soon she added corporations and other customers to her list, as well.

Tuohy, a Whimsy Cookie Company customer, approached Suriff in 2012 about starting a partnership. “I knew immediately that her product was one of the best things I had seen anywhere in the country. It had the potential to be something really great,” Tuohy said.

“I took Laurie out to lunch and discussed a five-year business plan and some goals for us as partners, as well as some benefits of teaming up,” Tuohy says. “She was ready to make the jump from a paid hobby to a real business.”

The two found a commercial kitchen in an industrial part of Memphis where they began developing their small business for online and phone orders. Oftentimes customers picking up their orders would ask about purchasing extra cookies, so Suriff and Tuohy built a small retail case in the production facility.

This sparked the idea of developing a bigger retail presence.  In 2012, they opened a store in the highest-end retail area in Memphis with enough space to hold events and display their cookies for in-store purchases.

“It surpassed our expectations,” Touhy says. “Our ceiling goals keep getting higher and higher. That’s what you should be doing as a small-business owner ― you should push yourself and reinvent your company and stay current. We’ve tried to do all of those things.”

Suriff and Tuohy constantly push themselves to give their customers more than expected from a cookie company. Their retail space includes a party room where they hold cookie-decorating parties for kids. Popular characters stop by to say hello, including Anna and Elsa from Disney’s Frozen and Santa Claus during the holidays. They host a weekly story time so busy parents can drop their kids off for a few hours while they run errands. And soon, Whimsy Cookie Company will have its own brand of coffee and a line of scented candles.

“We want every part of the experience to be high caliber because it has our name on it. We remind ourselves of that every day,” Tuohy says.

From good to great
Now that they’ve got the brick-and-mortar concept nailed down, they’re excited about expanding their e-commerce business. They realized that perfecting the quality of their product shipments was their next big step.

“I’d been shipping the cookies the same ways for years,” Suriff adds. “It worked pretty well, but it needed to be tweaked. It’s really important that our clients get their cookies in one piece.”

When packing their products for shipping via FedEx Ground, they wrapped the cookies individually in cello bags and lined them vertically against each other in the corner of a decorative box, which, they hoped, would minimize breakage. They placed that inside an outer box.

Even though 94 to 95 percent of their shipments arrived unbroken, Suriff and Tuohy wanted better results. They met with the packaging engineers at the FedEx Packaging Service lab to see what else they could do to protect their cookies even more. “Right off the bat FedEx had great suggestions for ways we could protect our products,” Tuohy says.

The taste of success
At the FedEx Packaging Lab, engineers Evan Edwards and Mickey Rainey analyzed the company’s packaging. They suggested a few changes to protect the decorative inner boxes and reduce cookie breakage:

  • Insert partitions inside the box to separate the cookies.
  • Position the cookies so the tops rest against the inside edges of the box for extra cushioning.
  • Use an outer shipping box that sits horizontally rather than vertically to help ensure the cookies are stacked on top of each other instead of on their sides.

Once these refinements were made, the engineers ran the new packaging through a series of tests to see how the cookies would withstand shipping. The new packaging passed each test and Suriff and Tuohy expect their shipping success rates will hit 99 percent.

“The people at the FedEx packaging lab were wonderful to work with,” Suriff says. “They were so knowledgeable, the process was easy, and they really understood us and our needs.”

“The Whimsy Cookie Company creates an edible, handmade, artistic product. When you’re delivering edible art, it has to be done as perfectly as possible,” Tuohy says. “If I can do something better, I need to do it better. If we can get our shipping success rate to go from 94 or 95 percent to 99 percent by changing the way we pack our cookies, that’s huge. FedEx is helping us do that.”

Want to discover better ways of packing your products? Request a free consultation with our packaging experts. Complete the form to test your packaging.

Please note

You are not using a recommended browser for this area of You may be able to use the site, however you may experience some difficulties. Fully supported browsers and operating systems include.

  • Microsoft Windows
  • Windows 200, XP, Vista
  • Google Chrome 13+
  • Microsoft Internet Explorer 8+
  • Mozilla Firefox 10+
  • Apple Mac OS
  • Mac 10.4+
  • Google Chrome 13+
  • Mozilla Firefox 10+
  • Safari 5.0+
  • iPad & iPhone
  • iOS 6+
  • Safari
  • Android
  • Android OS 4+ (Ice Cream Sandwich)
  • Chrome
  • Platform Browser